Nambucca Valley residents and community leaders are angry and disappointed with a 60 Minutes program filmed in Bowraville earlier this year.
On Sunday night the program aired a story about a group of young Bowraville Aboriginal students
who had won academic scholarships to some of Sydney’s elite non-government schools.
While the community applauded the future career and job opportunities now available to the students, they were concerned the underlying storyline of the 60 Minutes program could have a negative impact on the town.
Nambucca Shire mayor Rhonda Hoban said she was dismayed at the way 60 Minutes portrayed Bowraville.
“One of the comments made to me was that it put progress in Bowraville back 10 years because of the perception it portrayed,” Cr Hoban said.
“Bowraville has a wonderful sense of community. There are so many positives”.
Outrage, was how Bowraville Central School principal Malcolm McFarlane described the overwhelming feeling from within the school community.
“We don’t have a problem with students pursuing scholarships,” Mr McFarlane said.
“But to say there was nothing of value in Bowraville or the Nambucca Valley was an outrage,’ he said.
Mr McFarlane said the three scholarship students had not attended Bowraville Central.
“However, the journalist was on the (school) premises without permission and they did not liaise with the school,” he said.
“There were many clear implications that Bowraville and the Nambucca Valley were not worthy.
“They (the journalists) were factually wrong.
“They chose only to shoot demountable buildings; they only had to pan to see the $6 million capital works upgrade.”
Work has included the construction of a new science wing, primary and secondary classrooms, gymnasium and staff facilities.
“There are so many good news stories coming out of Bowraville.
“Last year we had the first-ever Year 12 (graduates) and two of the five were Aboriginal.”
He said the school’s upgrade
project had given apprenticeships to four local Aboriginal men.
“This is a huge positive for the Bowraville community.
“To suggest Bowraville is not worthy is farcical.”
Bowraville’s St Mary’s Primary School principal Claire Mellon said she was “very cranky” with the
program.
Ms Mellon said the show did not acknowledge her school – which initially educated the three young students – and instead focused on Bowraville Central.
“The schools in Bowraville are doing a great job,” Ms Mellon said.
She said despite the program’s claims, Bowraville schools offered students a good education.
“It is peer pressure from community groups or the culture of the community that holds them back.”
Since the scholarship program began, St Mary’s had assisted 16 students with scholarships to Sydney boarding schools.
All students have remained with the programs, with the first student now studying law at Macquarie University.
“These kids would not do so well at the boarding schools if they did not have a good start with schools in Bowraville.”
She said boarding schools for these students broadened their horizons, and they were in a structured and supportive environment, where they do not go off track.
Bowraville Chamber of Commerce president, Mark Scott said he got the general feeling the story was both positive and negative.
“The local education could have come out in a better light,” Mr Scott said. “There have been lots of successes in the past.
“It is great there are schools offering opportunities, but our schools here are offering lots of positive choices in the area.”
On the positive side, the program showed local scenes and the river.
“On the whole, the story was positive.”
Blew Maning, who works at the Frank Partridge Military Museum, described the scholarship program ‘great for the kids’.
However, Mr Maning was concerned with the perception that if these children had not been ‘rescued’ from Bowraville they would have ended up drunks in the gutters or criminals.
“That is the picture they (60 Minutes) painted,” Mr Maning said.“Hopefully people will look and say that could not be right and they will come and look for themselves.
“But, I think it will frighten people off; I hope it doesn’t.”